oleg.m/waggle-os
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Files
0c3e2ead3beaffba9d5004ef7fd87d871d5e6886
waggle-os/docs/decisions/2026-05-02-track-e-arxiv-7-decisions.md
Oleg Maslov 0c3e2ead3b
Some checks failed
Installer Smoke / installer-smoke (push) Has been cancelled
Details
moving
2026-09-02 10:10:29 +02:00

7.8 KiB
Raw Blame History

LOCKED Decision — Track E Arxiv Skeleton 7-Decision Ratifikacija

Date: 2026-05-02 Status: LOCKED Author: PM (decision memo authored retroactively 2026-05-05 to close decisions/ folder gap iz consolidation 2026-05-04) Ratified by: Marko (interactive 7-decision sesija 2026-05-02 sa surgical refinements za odluke 1, 4, 6, 7; explicit "uradi to sve" 2026-05-05 to author missing decision memos) Binds: Arxiv preprint drafting kick-off, Path A+D combination endorsement strategy, 3-author roster, Day 0 decoupling od arxiv timing Cross-references:

  • research/2026-04-26-arxiv-paper/03-paper-skeleton-v2-2026-04-30.md (10-section skeleton + 7 decision points authored 2026-04-30)
  • decisions/2026-04-30-pre-launch-sprint-consolidation-LOCKED.md (Track E sequencing)
  • project_benchmark_strategy.md memorija (Pavlukhin EVOLVESCHEMA author atribucija LOCKED 2026-04-20)
  • project_pilot_2026_04_26_result.md memorija (multiplier teza conditional finding source)
  • project_gepa_faza1_closed_2026_04_29.md memorija (GEPA cross-family evidence source za §5.4)
  • project_n400_run_state_2026_04_24.md memorija (LoCoMo paper claim #1 LOCKED, +27.35-point methodology gap source)
  • Memory entry project_track_e_arxiv_closed_2026_05_02.md (point-in-time observation, primary source)

§1 — Trigger i steering kontekst

Track E iz pre-launch sprint-a — arxiv skeleton ratification kao gate za drafting kick-off. PM facilitirao 7-decision interactive sesiju sa Markom 2026-05-02. Marko prešao iz "ratify pojedinačno" u "sve ti, vec znas o celoj prici" steering delegacije za većinu odluka, ali zadržao surgical refinements za 4 framing odluke (4, 6, 7, plus title 1).

§2 — Sedam ratifikovanih odluka

Odluka 1 — Title

Final: "Apples-to-Apples on LoCoMo: A Bitemporal Local-First Memory Substrate and a +27.35-Point Methodology Gap."

Marko-revised, methodology-led, +27.35 hook. Rejected PM rec za cross-family generalization title (sekundarna narrativna linija).

Abstract reorder: 1. rečenica methodological, 2. architectural, 3. brojevi.

Odluka 2 — Co-author roster

Final: 3-author paper.

  • Marko (lead/corresponding)
  • Pavlukhin (Egzakta tech lead, EVOLVESCHEMA author per project_benchmark_strategy LOCK 2026-04-20)
  • Barać (Full Professor FON UB, e-business)

Co-author 2 (methodology consult slot) DROPPED — Barać preuzima cross-check rolu pored academic advisor.

Odluka 3 — Endorsement path A+D combination

Path A primary (Marko 2026-05-03 ponedeljak): Pavlukhin podnosi EVOLVESCHEMA na arxiv kao standalone short preprint (4-6 strana, cs.AI). Posle arxiv approval (~24h), Pavlukhin endorses Markov paper kao nezavisni researcher (NE mora biti coauthor). Single email request to direct contact, ne cold outreach. Timeline 5-6 dana to endorsement-ready, compatible sa Day 0 ETA 6-10 dana.

Path D fallback decoupling: Day 0 launch decoupled od arxiv timing. Landing Trust Band Card 4 "Published methodology — arxiv preprint" zamenjuje se sa "Open methodology — github docs" (markdown methodology doc u OSS repo). Arxiv preprint linkujemo retroactively post-launch news cycle.

Odluka 4 — Multiplier disclosure

Final: Eksplicitna "Negative Result" subsekcija u §6 Discussion sa 5 elemenata:

  1. Hypothesis (multiplier teza)
  2. N=12 protocol
  3. Brojevi h2=1/3, h3=0/3, h4=0/3
  4. Preconditions for re-test imenovane
  5. Qualification "ne aplicira na primary contribution"

NOT "deferred" framing u headline — to ide u footnote.

Odluka 5 — GEPA scope §5.4

Final: Zadržava ~1.5 page sub-section format (PM rec a). Plus footnote: "Extended cross-family treatment in companion paper, in preparation."

Razlog: standalone §5 GEPA bi koštao desk-reject rizika; cross-family generalization je dovoljno jako da nosi sopstveni preprint za 6-8 nedelja sa ERL methodology framing.

Odluka 6 — §5.5 framing

Final: ACTIVE-VOICE rewrite — "Bias-detection guardrails functioning as designed". NE "methodology maturity demonstration" (defanzivno).

Aktivni glagoli:

  • "GPT selection bias detected and filtered by held-out"
  • "qwen-non-thinking decoupling probe revealed effect"
  • "calibration evolved across Amendments 7-11"

Odluka 7 — Forward reference §5.6

Final: REVISED statement: "Production traffic Pass II rates, p95 latency, and recall@K on production traffic distribution from Phase 5 deployment will be reported in v2 of this preprint, scheduled within 60 days post-publication."

Refinement 1: "expected ~6 weeks" → "scheduled within 60 days" (operational discipline + 14-day margin). Refinement 2: Imenovane konkretne metrike (Pass II rates + p95 latency + recall@K) — vague forward reference izgleda kao vaporware, specifična obećana metrika izgleda kao discipline.

§3 — Marko net evaluation note

PM intencije sve ispravne; tri od četiri framing-a (4, 6, 7) treba da se pomere stepenicu ka aktivnijem, ne dodatak na sadržaj. Cilj nije da paper deluje skromno ili pažljivo — cilj je da deluje tačno.

§4 — Drafting kick-off prerequisites (sve resolved)

  • ✅ Title locked
  • ✅ Author roster (3-author final)
  • ✅ Endorsement path locked (A primary + D fallback)
  • ✅ Multiplier framing locked (Negative Result subsection)
  • ✅ GEPA scope locked (§5.4 sub-section + companion paper footnote)
  • ✅ §5.5 framing locked (active-voice bias-detection guardrails)
  • ✅ §5.6 forward reference locked (60-day scheduled + named metrics)

§5 — Posledice za pre-launch sprint i downstream

  1. Drafting can start immediately ne blokira Day 0 launch. Sa A+D combination, arxiv timing više nije Day 0 launch dependency — Day 0 može da se ship-uje sa Path D landing implementation, arxiv preprint dolazi kao post-launch news cycle.

  2. PM full drafting sequence: Abstract → §1 Intro → §2 Related Work → §3 Architecture → §4 Methodology → §5 Results → §6 Discussion sa Negative Result subsec → §7 Conclusion. 7-9 dana PM autoring time, sledi Marko 1-2 dana review, total ~10 dana to submission.

  3. Apps/www CC Sesija D §3 acceptance review treba dobiti Trust Band Card 4 copy swap napomenu ("Open methodology — github docs" replace "Published methodology — arxiv preprint" za Day 0; revertable na arxiv reference posle Path A endorsement).

  4. Pavlukhin contact-initiation Marko-side ponedeljak 2026-05-03.

  5. Methodology markdown doc skeleton za github post Day 0 launch (PM action item). Završeno 2026-05-02 kao strategy/methodology/2026-05-02-methodology-doc-FINAL.md (13.2 KB), Marko-side action: copy u waggle-os/docs/methodology.md + git commit + push (resolved 2026-05-03 commit 87b1637).

§6 — Memory correction (2026-05-02)

Prior memorija project_benchmark_strategy.md LOCK 2026-04-20 atribucija "Pavlukhin = EVOLVESCHEMA author" je CONFIRMED ACCURATE. Prior PM web search miss (arxiv author profile 404 + zero hits) je explained by: EVOLVESCHEMA paper trenutno NIJE na arxiv-u (Marko had PDF locally on 2026-04-20 upload; paper not indexed publicly). Path A action will resolve that — Pavlukhin submits EVOLVESCHEMA standalone arxiv preprint, becomes arxiv author, becomes endorser-eligible.

§7 — Authoring trace

Ova decision memo je autorizovana retroactively 2026-05-05 kao deo pop-up-a četiri-fajla decisions/ folder gap-a koji je flagovan u project_execution_state.md snapshot 2026-05-04. Sadržaj reflektuje point-in-time observation iz project_track_e_arxiv_closed_2026_05_02.md memorije.

Razlog za retroaktivnu autorizaciju: per CLAUDE.md decision memo discipline, svaka LOCKED odluka mora imati matching decisions/<date>-<topic>.md fajl. Memorija postoji ali memorija nije auditable artifact (živi u Cowork space-u, nije u git-u).

END DECISION MEMO.

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink