waggle-os/docs/audits/2026-07-08-five-persona-judge-scorecards.md

Five-Persona UX Judge Scorecards

Companion artifacts:

• docs/audits/2026-07-08-complete-ux-usage-audit.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-ux-route-scenario-manifest.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-ux-state-failure-scenario-matrix.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-ux-non-main-surface-scope.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-ux-correction-register.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-five-persona-judge-runbook.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-source-inventory-consistency-audit.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-state-failure-t12-analysis.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-mobile-executive-t2-t12-analysis.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-runtime-a11y-t10-analysis.md
• docs/audits/2026-07-08-first-run-onboarding-t1-t2-t12-analysis.md
• docs/superpowers/plans/2026-07-08-ux-phase-1-corrections.md

Purpose: define the final judge gate before any claim that Waggle OS is 9/10 across five personas. These scorecards extend the existing tests/vision/personas.spec.ts harness. That harness proves live persona chat, persistence, screenshots, and no cross-persona prompt leakage; it does not yet score the full route/UX rubric.

Final status (2026-07-13): the fixed-rubric in-product judge run is complete. All five personas score at least 9/10 with no score cap triggered. The historical pre-fix findings and table below are retained as the audit trail; the final table at the end of this document supersedes them. Public launch availability is reported separately and is not silently counted as passing: waggle-os.ai is currently unresolved, and signed production distribution plus credential-dependent external-provider smokes remain release gates.

Execution protocol: use docs/audits/2026-07-08-five-persona-judge-runbook.md after the blocking tickets are fixed or explicitly deferred. The runbook is the authoritative checklist for state bundles, screenshots, score caps, and deferral records.

Phase 1 status update: the approved Phase 1 implementation is complete and verified. The standard cockpit lane now has clean accountless Clerk/CSP behavior, passing mobile Settings and mobile first-run onboarding checks, active Solo/Teams/Enterprise copy cleanup, passing Ctrl+Shift+N and Workspace Switcher route behavior, updated visual baselines, and codified thin-route evidence. The full combined browser gate passed 156/156 on port 34150. Phase 2 has started with partial overlay fixes: Notification Inbox and Create Workspace primary/subdialog contracts now have named dialog/close coverage, custom-template delete uses an in-app confirmation, the sampled 390 x 844 Create Workspace hierarchy prioritizes required setup before optional templates, Context Rail has a labelled complementary contract, Onboarding Tooltips has an explicit non-modal Escape-dismiss contract, and tier-modal close labels are named. These remove some overlay caps, but the final 9/10 gate is still blocked by remaining trust-critical dialogs, screenshot/state refresh, broader runtime accessibility, and T13-T19 non-main evidence unless those are fixed or explicitly deferred.

Non-Negotiable Gate

Do not run the final scoring pass until all are true:

1. No open P0 findings in the main audit.
2. Phase 1 verification lane passes or has explicitly approved visual baseline updates. Current status: passed 156/156 in the combined browser gate on 2026-07-08.
3. Route manifest has an evidence owner for every registered route and major overlay.
4. State/failure matrix has an evidence owner or approved deferral for each persona's required state bundle.
5. Standard browser lane has zero critical app/auth/CSP console errors.
6. Mobile Settings, first-run onboarding Profile, billing/profile, Home, Memory, Chat, and the selected overlay path have current 390 px screenshots plus visible element-bounds checks; focused Create Workspace bounds now pass, but document-level overflow alone is not enough.
7. No active user-facing Pro upgrade copy remains outside explicit legacy billing servicing.
8. Trust-critical destructive flows use in-app confirmation/result states.
9. Runtime T10 axe/DOM findings and shell-overlay semantics/close findings on judge routes are fixed or explicitly capped/deferred.
10. Public launch funnel, desktop wrapper, utility, hook, Browser Companion extension, developer/substrate, ops/deployment, CI, benchmark, and judging gates have evidence, or the user explicitly defers T13/T14/T15/T16/T17/T18/T19 from the five-persona score.

If any item fails, judges can still provide feedback, but their score is advisory and cannot satisfy the goal.

Scoring Model

Each persona scores 10 points:

Dimension	Points	Judge asks
Functional completion	2	Did the route/flow complete without broken state, dead end, or hidden dependency?
Flow, IA, and discoverability	2	Did the next action feel obvious without reading docs? Was the route in the right place?
Trust, error handling, and recovery	2	Were permissions, data consequences, pricing, model state, and recovery clear?
Visual, accessibility, and responsive quality	2	Did it feel designed, readable, keyboardable, and usable on required viewport(s)?
Performance and polish	1	Did it load and respond with no distracting lag, flicker, warnings, or noisy states?
Memory, personalization, and domain fit	1	Did Waggle remember/use context in a way that made the experience meaningfully better?

Pass rules:

• Every persona must score at least 9/10.
• No dimension may score below 8/10 when normalized to a 10-point scale.
• Any critical console error caps the affected persona at 7/10.
• Any blocked primary route caps the affected persona at 6/10.
• Any severe mobile clipping/overflow in a required mobile journey caps the affected persona at 7/10.
• Any selected overlay that opens but cannot close in the required persona path caps the affected persona at 7/10.
• Any selected overlay with no accessible name/landmark or unnamed primary icon-only actions caps the affected persona at 8/10 unless explicitly deferred.
• Native browser dialog in a trust-critical step caps that persona at 8/10.
• Critical axe finding in a persona primary route caps that persona at 8/10; serious keyboard access findings cap at 8/10 unless explicitly deferred from that persona's route.

Evidence required for every scorecard:

• Route list covered.
• State bundle covered: account mode, billing tier, disclosure tier, model state, data state, offline/error state, and viewport.
• T12 focused supplement checked for current state-slice evidence, native-dialog caps, and persona bundle corrections.
• First-run onboarding supplement checked for clean-data console health, mobile Profile bounds, import consequence clarity, and first-task handoff behavior.
• Non-main gate decision: T13/T14/T15/T16/T17/T18/T19 evidence attached or explicitly deferred.
• Evidence folder from the judge runbook.
• Screenshots inspected.
• Console status.
• Failing or flaky tests relevant to the persona.
• Score per dimension.
• Free-text verdict: pass, advisory pass, fail.
• Top 3 remaining corrections, if any.

Persona 1: Solo Founder

Profile:

• Maya, solo founder, pre-revenue, 4 months runway.
• Wants one clear next move and hates re-explaining context.
• Low patience for setup friction.

State bundle to capture:

• Account mode: accountless local.
• Billing tier: Solo / FREE.
• UI disclosure tier: simple first; power only for route evidence if needed.
• Model state: no-model recovery plus working-model or skipped-LLM explanation.
• Data state: fresh install, no workspace first, then one created workspace.
• Offline/error state: accountless Clerk/CSP lane.
• Viewport: desktop 1440 x 900 plus mobile Home/Profile spot-check.
• Non-main gate decisions: T13/T14 deferred or evidenced if launch/desktop flows enter this score.

Primary journey:

1. Start from /auth in accountless local-first mode.
2. Complete or bypass first-run onboarding.
3. Land on /home.
4. Use Home Start Here to open or create a workspace.
5. Send first chat asking for this week's one focus.
6. Add runway constraint and verify Waggle can reuse that context.
7. Return to Home and see a logical next action.

Required routes and overlays:

• /auth
• Onboarding Wizard
• /home
• /workspaces
• /workspaces/:workspaceId/chat
• Settings model gate or model setup affordance
• Workspace Switcher if no workspace exists

Evidence to collect:

• Desktop screenshots: auth/accountless, clean-data onboarding steps, Home, workspace chat, returned Home.
• Mobile screenshots: first-run Welcome and Profile at 390 x 844, with primary action bounds checked.
• Console summary: no Clerk/CSP errors in accountless mode.
• Transcript artifact showing context persistence or clear explanation of memory behavior.
• Route manifest rows for Auth, Home, Workspaces, Workspace.

Automatic fail triggers:

• Accountless local mode shows Clerk load errors.
• First-run onboarding emits Clerk/CSP console errors.
• Mobile onboarding hides the primary action in the first-run Profile step when mobile is in scope.
• First useful action is unclear from Home.
• Chat cannot accept first message or silently depends on unavailable LLM.
• Pro copy appears in the journey.

Corrections that must land before this judge can pass:

• T1 local auth/CSP/accountless health is closed for the standard accountless lane.
• T2 first-run mobile onboarding primary-action reachability is closed for the codified 390 px check.
• T3 Solo/Teams/Enterprise copy cleanup is closed for active Phase 1 surfaces.
• T4 shortcut/workspace context is closed for the codified Ctrl+Shift+N lane.
• T11 route evidence owner is closed for the Phase 1 thin-route shell smoke; deeper state evidence remains.

Expected 9/10 behavior:

• Maya understands what to do within 10 seconds of landing on Home.
• The app helps her move from broad anxiety to one concrete workspace/chat action.
• Memory behavior is honest and useful, not vague marketing copy.

Persona 2: Researcher

Profile:

• Chen, meticulous researcher validating persistent memory and provenance.
• Wants evidence, not vibes.
• Tolerates density if the information architecture is trustworthy.

State bundle to capture:

• Account mode: accountless or authenticated, but declared.
• Billing tier: Solo unless Teams memory/governance is intentionally tested.
• UI disclosure tier: power.
• Model state: working or skipped-LLM with memory UI focus.
• Data state: populated memory plus empty/no-result state, including sampled slow Memory, large Memory, and Timeline/Event states.
• Offline/error state: missing source, failed export, or trust/destructive recovery path.
• Viewport: desktop 1440 x 900; mobile Memory spot-check if scored.
• Non-main gate decisions: T19 evidenced or explicitly deferred if browser capture enters this score.

Primary journey:

1. Open /memory.
2. Search memory or inspect available memory records.
3. Open memory trust/provenance detail.
4. Visit wiki/timeline/evolution-related views.
5. Attempt export or delete/archive trust flow.
6. Return to chat and ask whether memory is durable versus long context.

Required routes and overlays:

• /memory/:mindScope?
• Memory trust/manage overlays
• Wiki tab
• Timeline/evolution tabs or /settings/timeline
• Workspace chat
• Native prompt replacements for wiki/export/delete

Evidence to collect:

• Screenshots: Memory overview, search result, trust/provenance detail, wiki/timeline state, confirmation modal.
• Console summary.
• Transcript or UI text explaining memory mechanism honestly.
• Route manifest rows for Memory and Timeline.
• Current partial evidence: Artifact permanent delete, Memory Center delete/GDPR erase/allow re-import, and Wiki Obsidian/Notion exports now have component coverage and rendered J3e/J3f/J3g evidence for in-app confirmations/forms. The five-persona bundle also covers memory-slow-list with a delayed Memory API and loading status, memory-large-list with 200 mocked memories, timeline-large-events with 360 mocked events, and wiki-export-obsidian-failure with branded Export Failed copy after a mocked 500.

Automatic fail triggers:

• Broader Notion/export variants remain open; Artifact permanent delete, Memory Center delete/erase/re-import, Wiki export destinations, and one rendered Wiki export-failure path are fixed for the sampled paths.
• Search/provenance route shows blank or unexplained empty state.
• Long memory titles break layout.
• App implies memory is magic without explaining limits.

Corrections that must land before this judge can pass:

• T5 approved baseline update for Memory after the fresh classification note.
• T7 trust-critical dialogs.
• T10 form/accessibility hygiene where memory forms are touched.
• T11 route evidence owner.

Expected 9/10 behavior:

• Chen can understand what is stored, why it is trusted, where it came from, and how to correct/remove it.
• Empty states and provenance states are credible, not decorative.

Persona 3: Engineer / Power User

Profile:

• Sam, senior engineer and agent wrangler.
• Wants keyboard speed, tool clarity, logs, and proof the product is not a chatbot wrapper.
• Low tolerance for flaky tests or hidden network dependency.

State bundle to capture:

• Account mode: accountless local.
• Billing tier: Solo, with Teams-only surfaces evidenced or deferred.
• UI disclosure tier: power or admin.
• Model state: local/no-LLM plus working-provider lane if chat is scored.
• Data state: one workspace, detected or undetected tools, MCP catalog present.
• Offline/error state: marketplace local-only, delayed/large Agents roster, and tool/hook unavailable states.
• Viewport: desktop 1440 x 900 plus keyboard-only path.
• Non-main gate decisions: T15/T16/T17/T18 evidenced or explicitly deferred for utility, hook, developer, and ops surfaces.

Primary journey:

1. Start on /home.
2. Open Command Center with Ctrl+K and navigate to an app.
3. Use Ctrl+Shift+N to open active workspace chat.
4. Open /launcher and verify tool/hook state.
5. Open /mcps, inspect installed/custom MCP server flows.
6. Open /files and inspect file actions.
7. Open /settings/events for logs.

Required routes and overlays:

• Command Center
• /workspaces/:workspaceId/chat
• /launcher
• /mcps
• /files
• /settings/events
• Workspace Switcher

Evidence to collect:

• Screenshots: Command Center search, chat after shortcut, Launcher, MCP Hub, Files, Events.
• Keyboard interaction log for Ctrl+K, Ctrl+Shift+N, Escape close.
• Console summary.
• Route manifest rows for Launcher, MCP Hub, Files, Events.
• Codified route smoke evidence: J-route-coverage: priority thin routes render meaningful shells passed for /launcher, /launcher?watch=1, /mcps, and /files on 2026-07-08.

Automatic fail triggers:

• Ctrl+Shift+N does not open the expected chat route.
• Workspace Switcher blocks unrelated navigation.
• Marketplace/MCP/Launcher depends on live external sync in the standard audit lane.
• Tool output renders broken JSON or unexplained fallback.

Corrections that must land before this judge can pass:

• T4 shortcut and Workspace Switcher route contract is closed for the standard browser lane.
• T6 marketplace determinism.
• T8 performance and payload polish if startup feels heavy.
• T11 route coverage for Launcher/MCP/files has shell-level smoke coverage; keep deeper hook/MCP/file interaction states in Sam's evidence bundle.
• T16 hook lifecycle if Launcher/tool management is included in Sam's final score.

Current partial evidence: the five-persona bundle covers agents-slow-list with a delayed /api/agents response, aria-busy Loading agents status, and final 40 agents plus Bulk Agent 000 roster proof; it also covers agents-large-list with 180 mocked agents and 0 visible overflow. These are accountless/no-LLM sampled state proofs, not substitutes for packaged hook lifecycle or authenticated Team evidence.

Expected 9/10 behavior:

• Sam can operate primarily by keyboard, sees real tool/hook state, and trusts logs/error states.
• The product feels like an agent OS, not a pile of screens.

Persona 4: Team Admin / Security Reviewer

Profile:

• Priya, nontechnical but accountable team/product admin.
• Needs plain language, billing confidence, governance, vault, backup, approvals.
• Cares about not breaking data or exposing secrets.

State bundle to capture:

• Account mode: authenticated, or accountless with mocked Teams-tier billing/admin state and limitations declared.
• Billing tier: Teams for team/admin surfaces, Solo for gating comparison, legacy Pro collapsed to Solo where relevant; real Team server membership must be evidenced or deferred separately.
• UI disclosure tier: professional and admin.
• Model state: not central unless Settings model copy is inspected.
• Data state: vault item, approval grant, backup metadata, team governance state, and unlocked Team settings state.
• Offline/error state: backup failure, restore failure, and checkout recovery copy.
• Viewport: desktop 1440 x 900 plus mobile Settings/Profile spot-check.
• Non-main gate decisions: T13/T14/T15 evidenced or explicitly deferred for launch, desktop, and admin/utility paths.

Primary journey:

1. Open /settings billing/general/model sections.
2. Visit /settings/vault.
3. Add or inspect a secret without revealing value.
4. Visit /approvals and review/revoke grants.
5. Use backup create/restore flow.
6. Visit /team governance.
7. Exercise payment success and payment cancelled recovery.

Required routes and overlays:

• /settings
• /settings/vault
• /approvals
• Backup section in Settings or Backup app surface
• /team
• /payment-success
• /payment-cancelled
• Erase Data dialog if destructive data flow is inspected

Evidence to collect:

• Screenshots: billing copy, active Team billing state, unlocked Team settings state, vault, approval list, backup flow, team governance, payment success/cancelled recovery.
• Console summary.
• Copy scan: no active Pro upgrade language except explicit legacy billing state.
• Confirmation/result-state screenshots for restore/revoke/delete.
• Current partial evidence: Approvals revoke-all now has component coverage, rendered /approvals J3d evidence for an in-app confirmation, and five-persona Team Admin bundle evidence via approvals-revoke-all-grants; Artifact permanent delete also has rendered J3e evidence; Settings telemetry clear/backup failure/restore success have settings-trust.test.tsx and rendered J3h evidence; standalone BackupApp restore, Automation delete, compliance template delete, and admin-web member removal have focused component evidence. The five-persona Team Admin bundle now covers approvals-revoke-all-grants, billing-team-active-state with mocked TEAMS tier and visible Waggle Team / $49/mo per seat / Manage subscription copy, team-settings-unlocked-state with visible Team Server URL/Auth Token/trust-warning copy, billing-checkout-success-return with a mocked Team checkout sync, billing-checkout-cancel-return with visible Checkout was cancelled / No charge was made recovery copy, billing-checkout-unavailable, backup-create-failure, and backup-restore-failure, with 0 critical console/page/network failures and 0 visible overflow. Current high-confidence production native-dialog scan is clean.
• Codified route smoke evidence: J-route-coverage passed for /payment-success and /payment-cancelled, including redirect to /settings?tab=billing, on 2026-07-08; the refreshed route smoke on 2026-07-09 still passes after adding the checkout=cancelled marker.

Automatic fail triggers:

• Billing copy says Pro as an active tier.
• Secret values are exposed unintentionally.
• Current known production native dialog scan is clean; remaining risk is uncodified less-common destructive paths, failure-state depth, and focus/keyboard proof rather than known browser-native alert/confirm calls.
• Payment cancelled lacks visible no-charge recovery copy.

Corrections that must land before this judge can pass:

• T3 pricing/gating copy.
• T7 trust-critical dialogs.
• T10 form/accessibility hygiene.
• T11 route coverage and the five-persona Team Admin bundle now cover payment cancelled, payment success return, mocked active Team billing, and unlocked Team settings states; real authenticated Team server/admin states still need persona screenshots or deferral.

Expected 9/10 behavior:

• Priya can tell what plan she is on, what actions are risky, and what happened after each admin action.
• The interface feels safe, not scary.

Persona 5: Mobile Executive

Profile:

• Mobile or tablet user checking status between meetings.
• Does not want to configure everything, but needs Home, Settings, Memory, billing/profile, and theme to work.
• Sensitive to clipping, tiny targets, and scroll traps.

State bundle to capture:

• Account mode: accountless local.
• Billing tier: Solo unless Team account view is intentionally sampled.
• UI disclosure tier: simple, with power only as a route-discovery comparison.
• Model state: no-model or verified-model banner must fit.
• Data state: at least one workspace and some memory.
• Offline/error state: overlay close plus readable empty/error state.
• Viewport: 390 x 844 primary; optional tablet 1024 x 768.
• Non-main gate decisions: T13/T14/T19 deferred or evidenced if launch, desktop, or browser-capture flows enter this mobile score.

Primary journey:

1. Set viewport to 390 x 844.
2. Open /home.
3. Open /settings.
4. Inspect billing/general/model/profile areas.
5. Open /settings/profile.
6. Open /memory.
7. Open workspace chat and send or type a short message.
8. Open Command Center or Workspace Switcher and close it with keyboard/touch equivalent.

Required routes and overlays:

• Mobile /home
• Mobile /settings
• Mobile /settings/profile
• Mobile /memory
• Mobile workspace chat
• Command Center or Workspace Switcher
• Billing/profile/theme controls

Evidence to collect:

• Mobile screenshots for every route above.
• Mobile first-run onboarding Welcome/Profile screenshots if the persona starts from a clean install.
• Horizontal overflow check.
• Critical visible control bounds check, because the fresh mobile smoke found clipped controls without document-level overflow.
• Focus/keyboard/touch target notes.
• Console summary.

Automatic fail triggers:

• Settings remains squeezed two-pane layout at 390 px.
• First-run onboarding hides the primary Continue action on the Profile step.
• Any primary billing/profile/model control is clipped or unreachable.
• Overlay traps scroll/focus.
• Selected overlay cannot close by keyboard/touch path.
• Selected overlay lacks an accessible name/landmark or leaves primary icon-only controls unnamed. Current update: Notification Inbox, Create Workspace primary/subdialog contracts, Context Rail, Onboarding Tooltips, and tier close controls have focused contract coverage; less common rendered states still need evidence.
• Create Workspace returns to a template-first mobile hierarchy in any judged path not covered by the focused 390 x 844 evidence.
• Text overlaps or becomes unreadable.

Corrections that must land before this judge can pass:

• T2 mobile Settings responsive layout is closed for general, models, billing, and profile in the codified 390 px check.
• T2 first-run onboarding responsive layout is closed for the codified mobile Profile reachability check.
• T3 pricing/gating copy is closed for active Phase 1 surfaces.
• T10 form/accessibility hygiene. Current update: core shell overlay semantics and sampled Create Workspace mobile hierarchy are partially fixed; broader T10 remains open.
• T11 mobile route evidence.
• T12 mobile state bundle, including selected overlay close evidence.

Expected 9/10 behavior:

• The app feels intentionally responsive, not merely shrunken.
• Mobile user can inspect and make small changes without fighting layout.

Judge Run Protocol

Preparation:

1. Build the app from current source.
2. Start a fresh-port local server with clean data unless testing return-state memory.
3. Run standard verification from the main audit.
4. Run or update route manifest evidence.
5. Capture required screenshots per persona.
6. Run tests/vision/personas.spec.ts only in a real-LLM lane, because it is not a no-LLM smoke test.

Scoring:

1. Fill the score table for one persona at a time.
2. Record exact blockers and route evidence.
3. Apply score caps before subjective scoring.
4. If a persona scores below 9, create a correction item or map it to an existing T-ticket.
5. Do not average away failures; all five must pass.

Suggested output table:

Persona	Functional /2	Flow /2	Trust /2	Visual+A11y /2	Perf /1	Memory fit /1	Total	Verdict	Blockers
Solo founder	Not Run	Not Run	Blocked	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Pre-fix blocked	P0-1, P0-3
Researcher	Not Run	Not Run	Blocked	Blocked	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Pre-fix blocked	P0-4, P1-1
Engineer	Blocked	Blocked	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Pre-fix blocked	P0-5, P0-6
Team admin	Not Run	Not Run	Blocked	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Pre-fix blocked	P0-1, P0-3, P1-1
Mobile executive	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Blocked	Not Run	Not Run	Not Run	Pre-fix blocked	P0-2, P0-7

Implementation Backlog Mapping

Scorecard blocker	Main ticket
Accountless Clerk/CSP console errors	T1
Mobile Settings squeezed/clipped	T2
Mobile first-run onboarding primary action hidden	T2/T12
Pro copy in active flows	T3
Ctrl+Shift+N mismatch and overlay trap	T4
Visual baselines classified as stale but not approved/updated	T5
Marketplace live sync and flaky search	T6
Native confirm/alert/prompt	T7
Heavy initial payload or delayed first meaningful UI	T8
Unknown local model cost semantics	T9
Labels/focus/icon-only buttons/noisy warnings	T10
Thin route coverage and judge harness gaps	T11
Missing state/failure bundle declaration	T12
Shell overlay semantics, close behavior, and Create Workspace mobile hierarchy	T10/T12
Canonical launch domains do not resolve; download has no releases; checkout, legal, and deploy gates remain open despite fresh localhost rendered evidence	T13
Desktop wrapper tray source is narrowed, but packaged tray, installer, update, and sidecar startup evidence is still missing	T14
Admin web, CLI launcher, Waggle CLI, legacy memory MCP, and hive-mind CLI still have blocking rendered/admin and built-entry issues; marketplace CLI first-command path is locally fixed	T15
AI-tool hook lifecycle has partial rendered Launcher evidence but still lacks real-tool/package invocation proof and clear result/unsupported-output UX	T16
Developer API, background worker, and substrate verification evidence missing	T17
Ops, deployment, CI, benchmark, and judging evidence missing	T18
Browser Companion auth/background save, popup keyboard/focus/Enter save, direct Save page click, restricted-page disabled-state recovery, stable packaged-ID pairing, Memory search provenance, existing chat auto_recall/catch-up provenance, and rendered Memory UI after secure save are live-proven, but native toolbar-bubble/native context-menu proof remains incomplete; future recall result shapes need evidence if scored	T19

Final Judge Run - 2026-07-13

This table scores the product UX itself. Each persona used a declared account, billing, disclosure, model, data, failure, and viewport state bundle. Captures waited for visible accessible loaders and route-specific legacy loading labels to settle, and animations were disabled for deterministic inspection.

Persona	Functional /2	Flow /2	Trust /2	Visual+A11y /2	Perf /1	Memory fit /1	Total	Verdict	Blocking corrections
Solo founder	1.9	1.9	1.8	1.9	0.9	1.0	9.4	Pass	None in scored lane
Researcher	1.9	1.8	2.0	1.9	0.9	1.0	9.5	Pass	None in scored lane
Engineer / power user	1.9	1.8	1.9	1.9	0.9	0.9	9.3	Pass	None in scored lane
Team admin / security reviewer	1.8	1.8	2.0	1.8	0.9	0.8	9.1	Pass	None in scored lane
Mobile executive	1.9	1.9	1.8	1.9	0.9	0.9	9.3	Pass	None in scored lane

Pass-rule checks:

• Lowest persona total: 9.1/10.
• Lowest normalized dimension: 8/10.
• Critical console errors: 0 across all five bundles.
• Page errors: 0 across all five bundles.
• Unexpected critical network failures: 0 across all five bundles.
• Visible horizontal overflow findings: 0 across route, failure, and overlay captures.
• Score caps triggered: none.

The five bundles exercise 15 primary route states, 25 failure/slow/large-data states, and 3 selected overlays. The run passed 5/5 in Chromium. Representative screenshots were inspected after the run, including settled Home, Memory, Launcher, Approvals, mobile Settings, and mobile Command Center states.

The detailed current-head evidence and release boundary are recorded in docs/audits/2026-07-13-final-goal-verification.md.