# Waggle V1 Pre-Production Qualification — COMPLETE

> **Historical snapshot — superseded.** The “then ship” and “You can ship”
> statements below record an older audit and are not a current release verdict.
> Use [`09-LAUNCH_RECOMMENDATION.md`](./09-LAUNCH_RECOMMENDATION.md) for the
> active Windows Solo gate.

**Date**: 2026-03-20
**Branch**: `phase8-wave-8f-ui-ux`
**Baseline**: 3,895 tests, 277 files, zero failures

---

## Read This First

**Recommendation: CONDITIONAL GO** — Fix 8 critical issues (~6.5 hours), then ship.

---

## Quick Numbers

| Metric | Value |
|--------|-------|
| Total issues found | 57 |
| CRITICAL (must fix) | 8 |
| HIGH (ship-week) | 22 |
| MEDIUM (V1.1) | 20 |
| LOW (backlog) | 7 |
| Fix effort (CRITICAL) | ~6.5 hours |
| Fix effort (all) | ~85 hours |
| Plan compliance | 54/60 slices (93%) |
| Overall confidence | 6.9/10 |

---

## The 8 Things That Block Ship

1. **CORS wide open** — Any website can call your APIs. Change `origin: true` to allowlist.
2. **SSE bypasses CORS** — Chat streaming echoes request origin. Use same allowlist.
3. **No error boundaries** — One React render error = permanent white screen.
4. **Refresh tokens plaintext** — Vault encrypts access tokens but not refresh tokens.
5. **CSP defeated** — `unsafe-eval` + `unsafe-inline` in server middleware.
6. **API key in git** — Redaction commit was empty. Verify key is revoked.
7. **Invisible loading** — Streaming dots have CSS classes with no definitions.
8. **Wrong splash colors** — First screen users see uses old navy-blue gradient.

**None of these require architectural changes. All are surgical fixes.**

---

## What's Strong

- Agent core: 53 tools, loop guards, injection scanning, approval gates
- Test suite: 3,895 tests, zero failures, strong behavioral coverage
- Feature set: All 8 Kill List use cases work
- Security fundamentals: AES-256-GCM vault, parameterized SQL, path protection
- Marketplace: 15K+ packages with SecurityGate vetting
- UX: Personas, dark/light mode, keyboard shortcuts, onboarding, memory import

---

## Report Index

| # | Report | What It Covers |
|---|--------|---------------|
| 01A | [Feature Waves](01A-FEATURE_WAVES.md) | Plan compliance for Waves 9A-9G + PM features |
| 01B | [Deployment + Phases](01B-DEPLOYMENT_PHASES.md) | Wave 9D deployment, Phase 7/8 status, PM features |
| 02 | [UX Audit](02-UX_AUDIT.md) | 7-view code review, Direction D, emotional assessment |
| 03A | [Agent Quality](03A-AGENT_QUALITY.md) | Agent loop, memory, vault, cron, connectors |
| 03B | [Server Quality](03B-SERVER_QUALITY.md) | API routes, CORS, SSE, WebSocket, KVARK |
| 03C | [UI Quality](03C-UI_QUALITY.md) | React patterns, TypeScript, error handling, bundle |
| 04A | [App Security](04A-APP_SECURITY.md) | CSP, vault crypto, tool safety, input validation |
| 04B | [Secrets + Deps](04B-SECRETS_DEPS.md) | Secret scanning, git history, npm audit |
| 05 | [Test Report](05-TEST_REPORT.md) | Coverage distribution, quality, gaps, Kill List |
| 06 | [Build Report](06-BUILD_REPORT.md) | Vite, Docker, Tauri, npx, Render, CI/CD |
| 07 | [Issue Register](07-ISSUE_REGISTER.md) | All 57 issues with severity, location, fix estimates |
| 08 | [Confidence Matrix](08-CONFIDENCE_MATRIX.md) | 8-dimension scoring with evidence |
| 09 | [Launch Recommendation](09-LAUNCH_RECOMMENDATION.md) | GO/NO-GO decision with fix roadmap |

---

## Suggested Fix Order

```
Day 0 (today, 6.5 hours):
  ├── PRQ-006: Verify API key revoked at Anthropic dashboard (5 min)
  ├── PRQ-001+002: Fix CORS allowlist + SSE endpoints (1.5 hr)
  ├── PRQ-005: Remove unsafe-eval/unsafe-inline from CSP (30 min)
  ├── PRQ-004: Encrypt refresh tokens in vault (1 hr)
  ├── PRQ-003: Add React error boundaries (2 hr)
  ├── PRQ-007: Fix streaming indicator CSS (15 min)
  └── PRQ-008: Fix splash screen colors (15 min)

Day 1-2 (security hardening):
  ├── PRQ-014: Auto-deny approval timeout (15 min)
  ├── PRQ-011+012: WebSocket auth (4 hr)
  ├── PRQ-020: Replace xlsx with exceljs (2 hr)
  └── PRQ-019: Generate updater keypair (30 min)

Day 3-5 (stability + build):
  ├── PRQ-009: Cap rate-limit retries (1 hr)
  ├── PRQ-026: Token budget enforcement (2 hr)
  ├── PRQ-015: Code splitting (2 hr)
  ├── PRQ-030: Fix TypeScript errors (2 hr)
  └── PRQ-029: Docker non-root user (30 min)
```

**After Day 0: You can ship.**
**After Day 5: V1.0.1 patch ready.**